Gary Neville questions Man Utd's decision to keep Michael Carrick

Gary Neville believes Manchester United’s decision to keep Michael Carrick in charge highlights the club’s lack of planning, insisting that sometimes a manager needs to be sacked for his own good. The former United captain shared his views after the club’s hierarchy decided to give Carrick more time despite a disastrous run of results.

United’s 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth extended their winless run to eight matches in all competitions and intensified the pressure on the head coach. Neville was surprised that Carrick remained in the job, believing the club’s decision may have been influenced by a lack of suitable alternatives rather than confidence in the manager.

Speaking on the Stick to Football podcast, Neville drew on his own experience as Valencia manager to explain his position. He recalled being relieved of his duties in Spain and admitted that the decision had ultimately been a relief. His argument was that dismissal can sometimes benefit both a struggling manager and the club.

Neville also directed criticism at Manchester United’s ownership, including the Glazer family, arguing that the club’s problems extend beyond the person in the dugout. He believes poor planning and a lack of accountability at the top have contributed to the team’s continued decline.

Despite the uncertainty surrounding his future, Carrick remains in charge ahead of Saturday’s Premier League trip to Chelsea. The coming matches could prove crucial as United attempt to halt their poor run and give their season some much-needed momentum.